FOREST ROAD, HURSTVILLE – A MOMENT IN TIME

The suburb of Hurstville in southern Sydney has long been a place of change. From transport hub to shopping megalopolis to high rise residential, the city hasn’t been spared the throng of development engulfing many centres around metropolitan Sydney. But Forest Road, the busy main thoroughfare lined with Asian eateries and grocery markets, still retains glimpses of architectural charm.

I enjoy a stroll along the bustling strip, now clearly influenced by a generation of Chinese migrants. Here you will stumble across butchers selling budget chops, rock star Vietnamese bakeries peddling pork rolls to the masses, Bok choy and Choy sum falling out of little boxes outside grocery stores, golden roast duck hanging gloriously from shopfront windows, noodle and dumpling bars exuding sweet aromas. And as its backdrop, a charming mixmatch of Victorian and Federation style shopfronts and art deco facades, even an early underground shopping arcade linking Forest Road to nearby Westfields, rumoured to be the first outside the Sydney CBD.

The place is a hive of activity, a successful working class migrant story, and it oozes an air of Oriental resourcefulness and prosperity. It’s good to see the Chinese community interact on Forest Road, the way they meet, the way they banter and communicate with one another. Elders are respected and their company is relished. You see it anywhere people of Asian backgrounds congregate. I believe westerners can learn from this sense of social connectivity on show.

But drastic change is once again in the air. A backflipping council, who previously claimed they would keep the CBD residential-free, now has big publicized development plans on the agenda. This is already taking shape along the northern stretch of Forest Road, just along from that massive former Amcor factory development, at 127-141 Forest Road, where a gaping hole has recently appeared and swallowed up a row of little shops and restaurants.

One of these shops was the Chinese grocer occupying Advance House, formerly known as Swans Hardware, a distinctive Art Deco warehouse that has been on the redevelopment radar for some time. There was a legal stoush between architect-developer Nick Katris (who also happens to be a Kogarah councillor) and Hurstville Council, which ended up in the Land and Environment Court. Katris and Associates lodged the original DA with no intention of keeping Advance House in any shape or form, but met an obstacle when Hurstville council’s heritage advisor, Graham Brooks, nominated retention of the Art Deco facade, being a listed item under Hurstville’s LEP. According to the court judgment, ‘Mr Brooks considered that there was an inherent conflict between the heritage listing in LEP 1994 and the site specific controls in the DCP, which permit large scale redevelopment that may overwhelm the retained element.’

At least they have left the façade for posterity, although far from acceptable, it’s better than nothing. It is only a wall after all, is that any substitute for a true heritage building?

The facade the was Advance House

The facade the was Advance House

DSC03273

DSC03275

Article from the Leader, 2010

Article from the Leader, 2010

Katris and Associates approved development

Katris and Associates approved development. The heritage facade is a little overwhelmed to say the least.

Further along, opposite the railway entrance sits the Stokland (former Fosseys) building, a landmark example of an early department store, and quite an elegant example of its type. This council-owned building is now for sale, under a profit taking scheme to bulldoze and replace it with a small park standing over several new levels of underground shopping (that must be a first for modern-day planners; you can have a park, but it needs to make money, there needs to be a shopping centre beneath it!). The existing historic arcade is also at risk.

Stockland, former Woolworths, Fosseys art deco store, 1951. To be demolished by council 2013

Stockland, former Woolworths, Fosseys art deco store, 1951. To be sold and demolished by council 2013.

Hurstville Council, under pressure from the NSW planning department, now appears intent on bulldozing much more of Hurstville’s historic main street. Now it’s been revealed that village centres Riverwood, Peakhurst, and Penshurst won’t be spared either under new zonings set by Minister Hazzard, despite Hurstville Council trying to ‘funnel’ high rise into the CBD. How much will survive now that high rise development will be allowed to encroach into Forest Road and other centres. Many of these buildings are over 100 years old, in essence, an ‘old town’ streetscape that should be retained and protected rather than turned into glass and concrete high-rise.

There is nothing more soulless than new glass shopfronts supporting multi-storey units. Many of us prefer the rambling, human scaled, colourful, sometimes crumbling shopfronts of a Hong Kong style market, where street life abounds and takes on a meaning of its own. This won’t be the case with new mega-development from architect firms such as Katris and Associates, swallowing up any heritage, any vibrant colour that now exists on the Forest Road strip; heritage that has evolved over time to take on new generations, and suit their needs, and provide all that is required for a healthy shopping precinct to exist into the future.

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

5 responses to “FOREST ROAD, HURSTVILLE – A MOMENT IN TIME”

  1. Dorothy says :

    What about the conflict of interest of the architect/developer being a councillor? This is happening far too often in our local councils now. There should be some way of controlling this but am not sure how 🙂 No wonder we are losing so much of our history – the developers are making sure they get on to council and then make the decisions – even if they abstain from voting, they have the money behind them to influence decisions.

    It is so depressing …..just about every day we read or hear about more and more of our history disappearing in the name of ‘progress’ and we seem powerless to stop it.

    What to do?

    • inheritanceorg says :

      Yes I too am concerned about the “day jobs” of many councillors, and their real reasons for entering local politics or even the state. As we have seen of late corruption is rife at many levels, and it generally starts at council. One way to avoid such conflicts of interest would be to place a ban on any councillor being involved with real estate/architecture/developer companies… this is what we should expect as a community from our council representatives… to represent US, the people, NOT their own real estate interests, but how can they when they themselves have a financial stake in the development and overdevelopment of our suburbs? To me it makes no sense.
      On one hand Barry O’Farrell’s white paper, which promises to take planning powers away from these councillors, may not be a bad concept in theory, but can he and the Liberals be trusted with absolute planning power in NSW? On track record to date, absolutely not. In fact the Liberal party at both state and local levels at this stage seem to be extremely pro-developer and anti-community biased. We are in real trouble no matter which way you cut it, especially as Australians don’t really seem to want to become involved and stand up for their own communities, and will most likely complain all the more when 6 and 7 storey developments sweep across their once quiet suburbs.

  2. Jimi k says :

    Although he is a councillor of Kogarah Council, and this new building is in Hurstville Council, i also see this as a conflict of interest. I would imagine what he would push through to Kogarah, and their demolishion of historic buildings.

    Sadly, i can see this strp of Forest Road being overturned from what it currently is (from the Queens Street intersection until the new development mentioned above) into a 4+ story apartment / retail buildings strip – in the near future.

    I just hope that the War Memorial remains in the same location. Oatley War Memorial did move grounds (from where the school is, to the current Memorial Park). Just hope Council has some faith in that respect.

    • fay mcelligott says :

      What a shame Hurstville has changed so much. I grew up there 1940-1960 and my relatives before me. Bond Street has fond memories of my Grandparents. Time should stand still sometimes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: